Can you solve this brain teaser?
After receiving an anonymous phone call, the police raid a house to arrest a suspected murderer. They don’t know what he looks like but they know his name is John and that he is inside the house. The police bust in on a doctor, a builder, a mechanic and a fireman all playing poker. Without hesitation or communication of any kind, they immediately arrest the fireman. How do they know they’ve got their man? (Answer at the end).
Everybody loves a good detective story. A crime is committed (usually a gruesome murder), and the hero detective steps in to solve the case and save the day. Sometimes the detective will work for the police force or forensics; other times they will be a private detective, working independently and outside of government networks. Whatever the case (pardon the pun), the detective nearly always catches the criminal. But why are they so popular?
There are a few contributing factors at work in mystery and thriller novels. The most obvious one is that people love going along for the ride behind the scenes of crime. Gruesome attacks and details pique the interest and imagination of many readers whose lives are filled with bland routine. Gory crimes become a comfortably confronting escape for readers who learn to appreciate the blandness of life without murders.
Another reason that readers love crime novels is to see how their deductive skills of detection stack up against the fictional professionals. I know I love to see if I can figure out the details of the murder before the end, working out who is only written in to be the red herring. For me it adds to the fun of reading, turning it from just a story to an interactive experience.
The final reason is to feel secure in the knowledge that we have some very smart people working together to solve the heinous crimes we see in the news, for sometimes, art can imitate life and vice versa.
I have always wondered whether police detectives-in-training are given a reading list of crime fiction to immerse them into the world and give them alternative perspectives.
- Sherlock Holmes created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
The most popular fictional character of all time, and not just in crime fiction, Doyle’s private detective has been featured in many spin-offs from movies and television shows, to pastiches and Young Sherlock series. It seems that we just can’t get enough of the genius crime-fighter with his drug addictions and love of violins and bees.I love reading the original stories (as well as the new stories released by other authors) for many reasons. Not only are they well-written, but using John Watson as the narrator makes it that much more exciting as opposed to the Doyle’s two short stories where Sherlock himself narrates the tale. My own amateur skills of deduction have been improved by applying Sherlock’s methods from the stories to real life, from finding lost keys to who ate my lunch. If you haven’t been acquainted with the original stories, then there’s no time like the present. In the words of Sherlock Holmes: “The game is afoot!” - Detective Tom Thorne created by Mark Billingham
A British copper who bends the rules to solve murders, and loves country music and beer. The aptly named Tom Thorne is a haunted, but loveable character who causes issues for all of his superior officers and murderers who think they’re smarter than The Force.I remember the first time I bought a Tom Thorne novel: Sleepyhead. A woman is discovered with a broken neck and suffering from locked-in syndrome (where you can only move your eyes). It turns out that this is the killer’s only successful attack (his previous ones had been killed). Thorne needs to catch the criminal before he or she kills again. The blurb intrigued me and then, after reading, I was hooked on Thorne. The following novels in the series were just as interesting, sparking two seasons of telemovies featuring David Morrisey as the titular detective. I love Billingham’s crime writing, including his solitary works where Tom Thorne usually has a cameo appearance. - Hercule Poirot created by Agatha Christie
The Belgian man with the moustache created by the highly acclaimed and prolific author, Agatha Christie. You may see him on television at the moment with David Suchet playing the lead role, but he is most known for solving the murders on the Orient Express (fictional of course). The killer in this story will surprise you (unless you have been given spoilers, of course).Poirot’s ability to sniff out the details and solve a crime cements his place at number three on my list of best detectives. - Cormoran Strike created by Robert Galbraith (J.K. Rowling)
One-legged, war veteran Strike came into the detective fiction world in a media frenzy. Writing under the pseudonym of Robert Galbraith, Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling explored the world of crime with her second novel for adults, The Cuckoo’s Calling. Strike is strapped for cash and in need of a softer cushion for his prosthetic leg, but with his new secretary Robin, he solves the stuffing out of a murder that is made to look like an accident/suicide. Already notorious for being the bastard son of a well-known rockstar, Strike gains more positive publicity for solving what the police couldn’t. - Dr Temperance Brennan created by Kathy Reichs
Played by Emily Deschanel on the popular television series, Bones, Dr Brennan is a forensic anthropologist who goes beyond her job description to solve the crimes. The television series is more based on Kathy Reichs’ life than the series of novels, and the character of Dr Brennan is ultimately different (including Book Brennan being a recovering alcoholic).If you want to see how medical practitioners share a hand in solving murders, then this is a crime series for you. They are similar in reading to Tess Gerritsen’s engaging novels, but I enjoy Reichs’ books more overall. - Detective Erika Foster created by Robert Bryndza.
With crime always going to be an issue in society (unfortunate, but true) and technology constantly evolving, crime fiction will always be a popular and significant genre enjoyed by audiences worldwide.
Answer to the riddle: The Fireman was the only male at the table. The doctor, builder and mechanic were all female.
Sidenote: I love this riddle because it uses gender stereotypes to trick the audience. It takes gender unbiased thinking to solve the riddle.
Scott G. Gibson is an independent author living in Queensland with his wife and children. Gibson is the author of five books: Place your hand in mine: An anthology; Making Tracks, a young adult novel; Bad Luck Bevin, a novel for younger readers; and two collections of speculative fiction and horror short stories, Shadows of a Nightmare and Shadows in the Flames.